Censoring critical voices: Social media giants fined; journalists, women HRDs behind bars
During this reporting period, two reports were published that address the current conditions for freedom of association in Turkey.
- Third Sector Foundation of Turkey (TUSEV) released the results of the second survey conducted to explore the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on Turkish CSOs. Yet, the survey showed that organisations working to empower disadvantaged groups such as children, refugees, the disabled and the elderly are facing greater challenges than CSOs operating in other areas. The results found that since the start of the pandemic, there is a declining trend in relation to the impact of the pandemic on some CSOs’ activities. A significant number of CSOs reported no difficulty in adapting to the new working order. When asked what support they needed to sustain employment and activities, the organisations shared that they wanted to increase the opportunities for corporate funds and develop cooperation between CSOs and public authorities.
- Civil Society Development Centre (STGM) published a report “Freedom of Association in Turkey” which suggests that there is a need for various transformations in the environment for CSOs to operate, particularly within legislation and implementation regarding freedom of association.
- The European Commission published its 2020 Enlargement Package report for Turkey which concluded that “serious backsliding” of the CSO environment continued in the country. Organisations were forced to close due to COVID-19 measures and were excluded from legislative consultative processes.
In a separate development, in a draft resolution, PACE’s Monitoring Committee condemned new crackdowns on political opposition and civil dissent. PACE addressed various concerns over Turkey’s external activities, including military operations, and urged the Turkish authorities to improve the conditions for democracy, the rule of law and human rights.
COVID-19 related developments
On 2nd October 2020, the Ministry of Interior announced that activities held by NGOs, unions and cooperatives were required to be postponed until 1st December 2020. This was due to the recommendation of the Health Ministry regarding COVID-19 measures.
The Turkish President ordered the Turkish Medical Association (TTB) to be outlawed and its leadership prosecuted. The TTB was accused for terrorism after the organisation criticised the government’s handling of the COVID-19 pandemic, including reporting correct numbers. In the past few months doctors have faced harassment and criminal charges for speaking out on COVID-19.
WHRDs targeted and arrested
After three waves of operations against it, eight women affiliated with Rosa Women’s Association were arrested while eight others were released on probation. In addition, there is a warrant out for two women, while one affiliated woman had already been released. The names of the arrested human rights defenders are: Adalet Kaya, Narin Gezgör, Fatma Gültekin, Rojda Barış, Gülistan Nazlıer, Gülcihan Şimşek, Remziye Sızıcı and Sevim Coşkun. The alleged accusation brought against them is being a “member of an armed terrorist group”. Some trials were held for the accused women with outcomes:
- Rojda Barış was sentenced to 6 years and 3 months in prison for “membership in a terrorist organisation” on 2nd November 2020.
- Narin Gezgör was sentenced to 7 years and 6 months in prison on 11th November 2020.
- Gülistan Nazlıer, who was tried without arrest, was sentenced to 6 years and 3 months in prison for “membership in a terrorist organisation” on 23rd December 2020.
- On the same day, Sevim Coşkun, who was on remand, was sentenced to 7 years in prison for “membership in a terrorist organisation” and 1 year and 6 months in prison for “resisting the police”. Coşkun has been released pending the finalisation of his sentence.
#Turkey’s war on #Kurds is also a war on the strong Kurdish Women’s Movement: Diyarbakir prosecutor demands up to seven years and six months jail for Narin Gezgör (@naringezgor), member of the Rosa Women’s Association in #Amed (@MAturkce) #TwitterKurds pic.twitter.com/EFgaD9PnJ7— Cahîda Dêrsim (@dersi4m) November 11, 2020
During this reporting period, several demonstrations took place:
- From 14th to 18th September 2020, The Turkish Medical Association staged several protest events against the government's mismanagement of the COVID-19 pandemic, under the slogan “You cannot govern, We are dying”. This included putting up posters in hospitals and pharmacies and marching in city centres.
Health workers in #Turkey staged a protest following the call by Turkey's Doctors Union @ttborgtr they wore black ribbons in remembrance of all of their colleagues who died fighting #Covid19 but also to remind all they have been fighting since day 1pic.twitter.com/4cVZ0rrP09— Güldenay Sonumut (@Guldenay007) September 18, 2020
- On 25th September 2020, the Turkish authorities ordered 82 arrests of pro-Kurdish People’s Democratic Party MPs and other notable pro-Kurdish figures over street protests that took place in 2014. The Prosecutor’s Office said in a statement that the group had been arrested for terrorists acts and propaganda.
Partimize karşı bu sabah başlatılan intikam saldırısının kararı dün yapılan MGK toplantısında, savcının Saray’daki düğün töreninde alınmıştır. AKP-MHP bloğu kaybettikçe muhalefeti tasfiye etmeye çalışıyor. HDP sizin darbelerinize boyun eğmedi, eğmeyecek. #HDPsusturulamaz pic.twitter.com/vsxNaVHtvP— HDP (@HDPgenelmerkezi) September 25, 2020
- Demonstrators gathered in Istanbul on 1st November 2020 to protest against French President Macron after his comments on Islamic religious rights and freedom of expression, which sparked protests in multiple countries around the world.
Journalists behind bars
Mumtazer Turkone, who was imprisoned in 2016 together with many other journalists at the time, was released from prison on 24th September 2020. Human rights groups have accused the Turkish government of attempting to silence journalists and the media since 2016. The Journalists’ Union of Turkey reported that 70 journalists and media workers are still imprisoned.
Eleven international rights groups, including Human Rights Watch (HRW), released a statement condemning the current state of press freedom in Turkey. The organisations went on a four-day mission from 6th to 9th October 2020, and declared that many journalists are currently behind bars, authorities continue to instrumentalise the justice system and that regulatory institutions lack independence. In a statement they called for authorities to ensure the prosecution of perpetrators responsible for physical attacks on journalists.
On 6th October 2020 four journalists were detained following their repeated reports on an incident where two Kurdish villagers were allegedly tortured and thrown from a helicopter. The European Federation of Journalists (EFJ) and the International Federation of Journalists (IFJ) demanded the immediate release of the journalists, arguing that such actions are proof that the Turkish authorities do not want a free press. The lawyer of two of the four journalists reported that individuals were subjected to ill-treatment in prison.
“Journalistic work is essential to uncover state abuses that otherwise remain hidden to the public and, therefore, go unpunished. These arrests are another scandalous proof that the Turkish authorities do not tolerate a free press. Adnan Bilen, Cemil Uğur, Şehriban Abi and Nazan Sala must immediately be released,” IFJ General Secretary Anthony Bellanger.”
In a separate case, on 7th December 2020, journalist Ayşegül Doğan was convicted for "establishing an armed organisation" and sentenced to six years and three months in prison. The basis of the charges is due to her broadcasts on İMC TV and the interviews she conducted with people who were part of the peace talks between Kurdish and Turkish citizens of Turkey. In a petition, The Coalition of Women in Journalism (CFWIJ) called for charges against the journalist to be dropped:
“Legal harassment of journalists through weaponisation of the law should no longer be used by the Turkish authorities, while the government and the public wish to join the European Union with afirm stance concerning fundamental rights.”
#CFWIJ launches a petition supporting journalist @aysegul__dogan as she faces six years in prison for her journalistic work. These practices both overshadow and threaten #PressFreedom. Please sign the petition: https://t.co/VJkLLR3X3v #JournalismIsNotACrime pic.twitter.com/9XKmgB0mKg— #WomenInJournalism (@CFWIJ) December 21, 2020
In a positive development, The European Court of Human Rights found that Turkey violated the freedom of expression of a group of journalists who during the ‘Cumhuriyet trial’ faced terrorism charges. The Court unanimously ruled that two articles of the European Convention on Human Rights had been violated, and ordered that Turkey pay fines to each of the applicants. In October 2016, Murat Sabuncu, editor-in-chief of Cumhuriyet publication and several journalists and board members from the foundation were arrested for “aiding an armed terrorist organisation without being its member." In April 2018, the court convicted 14 Cumhuriyet staff members. However in 2019 the Supreme Court overturned these convictions. During a retrial of the case all the accused were convicted once again, except for one who was acquitted.
The Journalists’ Association of Turkey published a report which found that censorship has increased rapidly, particularly after the introduction of a new law on digital rights, and the intensified penalties on the media. The report shows that the state issued 90 penalties on the independent media between July and September 2020. RSF’s concern about the new amendment is heightened by the fact that, since its adoption on 31st July 2020, RSF has registered no fewer than 347 cases of online articles being censored for constituting an insult, threat to national security or violation of the “right to be forgotten.”
“These new provisions give the Turkish government a great deal of control over social media and, if platforms comply with demands from the authorities, many online journalists could be under direct judicial threat. As all forms of online dissent have already been subjected to systematic and arbitrary interventions, an unprecedented level of censorship on platforms should be expected from today onwards,” RSF Turkey representative Erol Onderoglu.
In addition, RSF noted how some news websites have become completely inaccessible:
- On the same day that former parliamentarians and other prominent members of the pro-Kurdish party HDP were arrested (see above), the website of pro-Kurdish daily Yeni Yaşam was blocked by a local magistrate in Antakya.
- Website Radio Özgürüz, created by journalist Can Dündar, who is in self-imposed exile in Germany, was silenced by the Press Advertising Authority (BİK).
In a separate development, a pro-opposition television station, Halk TV, was given a five-day broadcasting ban after an anchor’s criticism of Turkish foreign policy. The channel’s Chief Editor responded by stating that censorship is typical in Turkey and an extension of the majority party’s attempt to silence opposing voices.
The resignation of Turkey’s Finance Minister on 8th November 2020 was met with silence by the Turkish media. Some have reported that this is an instance where self-censorship was practised by media outlets, as seen in the event of a political development in the country. A representative for Reporters without Borders stated that the silence of the media organisations in reporting the resignation marks the failure of their obligation to inform the public.
Doç. Dr. @cerensozeri “Resmi açıklamayla haber yapılacaksa medyaya ne gerek var?”; RSF’den @ErolOnderoglu da, “Medya cahilleştirme aracı olarak tehdit haline geldi” sözleriyle Albayrak’ın istifasını haber yapmayanları eleştirdi - DW Türkçe https://t.co/fpiN5jg9JR— RSF Türkçe (@RSF_tr) November 9, 2020
Social media giants fined
The Turkish authorities imposed fines of 10 million Turkish lira (one million Euros) to social media giants, including Facebook, Twitter and YouTube, for failing to comply with the new social media law. The law had been criticised by human rights groups, including Amnesty International and the UN for tightening controls on freedom of expression, as the law requires companies to respond within 48hours to the government’s requests to remove content and for tech giants to appoint a representative in Turkey. ARTICLE 19’s Head of Europe and Central Asia Sarah Clarke said:
“The Turkish Government is attempting to blackmail tech companies into accepting their proposals. They face either succumbing to the long arm of state censorship or having access to their platforms slowed so much that they are in effect blocked in Turkey.... The government claims this law is needed to protect personal rights, national security and public order. In reality, it will be used to censor critical voices and put individuals who speak out against the government at greater risk of criminal sanctions.”
In a separate development, in a joint statement, various media organisations addressed the adoption of the Universal Periodic Review (UPR) of the Human Rights Council outcome for Turkey. The organisations shared their discontent over the Turkish authorities’ response to the UPR, and actions taken to suppress free expression since the review.
Civic Space Developments